Papyrus P28: John 6:17–22 in a Greek Witness
P28, P.Oxy. XIII 1596, is a third-century papyrus fragment preserving John 6:8–12 and 17–22, formerly at the Badè Museum and now reported in a private collection.
- Artifact date
- 3rd Century
- Findspot
- Egypt; exact ancient findspot is not stated in the consulted manuscript catalogs
- Current location
- Private Collection, Los Angeles, California, Pap. 2
What archaeologists can actually examine
Papyrus 28 preserves portions of two separated scenes in John 6: the loaves and gathering of leftovers in verses 8–12, and the disciples' night crossing, Jesus' approach on the sea, and the crowd's next-day search in verses 17–22. Published as P.Oxy. XIII 1596, it comes from one fragment of a one-column papyrus book. Current catalogs date it to the third century. Its material history has an important modern complication: once Pacific School of Religion Papyrus 2 in the Badè Museum, it was sold in 2015 and is now listed with a private collector. That custody change affects access and accountability even though older photographs preserve the scholarly witness.
Two John 6 scenes survive
The fragment contains John 6:8–12 and 17–22, not only the sea-crossing verses emphasized in the title.
A fragment of a larger codex
Thirteen partial lines survive from a page reconstructed at roughly twenty-six lines, confirming extensive loss.
Excavated and published
Its Oxyrhynchus recovery and 1919 editio princeps secure its identity and distinguish it from unprovenanced market fragments.
Custody changed in 2015
Formerly Pacific School of Religion Papyrus 2, P28 is now reported in a Los Angeles private collection.
Follow the evidence from discovery to debate
Move through the find in a deliberate order: establish its provenance, examine the surviving object, place it in time, and then weigh the scholarly interpretation.
How the find came to light
Grenfell and Hunt excavated P28 at Oxyrhynchus in the 1905–1906 season and published it in 1919. The Egypt Exploration Society distributed it to the Pacific School of Religion in Berkeley, where it belonged to the Badè Museum of Biblical Archaeology as Papyrus 2. In April 2015 it was purchased by collector Gifford Combs, and CSNTM now lists a private collection in Los Angeles. The excavated origin and early publication secure the object's identity, but the transfer out of an institutional collection narrows public control over future examination. No surviving documentation names the ancient reader or proves that the book was manufactured at Oxyrhynchus rather than discarded there after use.
What you are looking at
The surviving papyrus is approximately 10.7 by 5.2 centimeters, reconstructed from a leaf around 23 by 13 centimeters. A single column contained roughly twenty-six lines, of which thirteen are partially extant, averaging perhaps twenty-nine to thirty-seven characters when complete. The hand is often described as documentary or informal. Text appears on both page faces as consecutive Johannine material, indicating a codex. Holes and lost margins interrupt the lines, and the two surviving verse blocks are separated by missing material rather than intentionally excerpted. The small sample contains enough letters for textual comparison but not enough to infer the appearance, decoration, title, or complete contents of the parent manuscript.
Where it belongs in history
Palaeographers usually assign P28 to the later third century or the third century broadly. One comparative record notes that the biblical writing reused papyrus associated with a third-century document, potentially offering contextual support, but the precise relationship of the documentary and literary layers must be described from the artifact rather than assumed. No colophon gives an exact year. The fragment belongs to an Egyptian environment in which John's Gospel is relatively well represented among early surviving Christian papyri. That pattern may reflect climate and excavation history as much as ancient popularity. The manuscript shows a practical codex circulating by this period; it does not establish when John was first composed or first reached Egypt.
Consensus, questions, and debate
Early editors compared P28's readings with major Greek witnesses and characterized it within an Alexandrian stream. The International Greek New Testament Project and modern collations instead encourage reading-by-reading analysis. With only eleven verses partly preserved, broad text-type labels can overstate how much of the lost Gospel is known. Scholars also must distinguish an original letter, a damaged trace, and an editorial supplement based on expected Johannine wording. The sale from the Badè Museum introduces a separate ethical and practical question: legal ownership is not the same as optimal scholarly accessibility. Consensus holds on identity, contents, Oxyrhynchus publication, and approximate date; the manuscript's full textual character and ancient provenance beyond recovery remain unavailable.
The biblical record beside the artifact
John 6:8–12 identifies Andrew, the boy with barley loaves and fish, Jesus' thanksgiving, the feeding, and the command to gather what remains. John 6:17–22 describes the disciples crossing toward Capernaum in darkness, the rough sea, Jesus walking near the boat, his 'It is I; be not afraid,' and the crowd realizing that Jesus had not departed in the only boat. P28 therefore preserves both provision and sea-crossing material that precede the Bread of Life discourse. The papyrus witnesses the Greek transmission of these narrative units. It neither supplies the missing intervening verses nor independently corroborates the miracle as an archaeological event.
John 6:17–22
17And entered into a ship, and went over the sea toward Capernaum. And it was now dark, and Jesus was not come to them.
18And the sea arose by reason of a great wind that blew.
19So when they had rowed about five and twenty or thirty furlongs, they see Jesus walking on the sea, and drawing nigh unto the ship: and they were afraid.
20But he saith unto them, It is I; be not afraid.
21Then they willingly received him into the ship: and immediately the ship was at the land whither they went.
22¶ The day following, when the people which stood on the other side of the sea saw that there was none other boat there, save that one whereinto his disciples were entered, and that Jesus went not with his disciples into the boat, but [that] his disciples were gone away alone;
A responsible historical conclusion
P28 gives physical form to a carefully connected portion of John 6. The same leaf once carried a story of abundant bread and a story of fear on the water, followed in the complete Gospel by teaching about heavenly bread. That arrangement reminds readers that fragments were once continuous books, not isolated proof texts. Its informal hand and papyrus material show an early Christian book at a scale far removed from later illuminated codices. The modern custody history matters as well: scholarship relies on trustworthy records, images, and continued access when culturally important manuscripts enter private hands. P28 is valuable for the text it preserves and as a case study in excavation, institutional stewardship, deaccession, and responsible claims from incomplete evidence.
Authoritative sources
Institutional catalogs, excavation reports, and academic publications let you examine the evidence beyond this summary.
Manuscript P28
Center for the Study of New Testament ManuscriptsProvides the updated private-collection location, material, date, format, line estimate, passages, and images.
P28 / P.Oxy. XIII 1596
Center for New Testament RestorationDocuments measurements, reconstructed leaf, excavation, museum custody, 2015 sale, current location, contents, and bibliography.
Location List of the Oxyrhynchus Papyri
University of Oxford, Oxyrhynchus Papyri ProjectProvides the project-level custody framework for distributed Oxyrhynchus papyri and supports the historical institutional identification of P.Oxy. 1596.
Early New Testament Manuscripts and Their Dates
Ephemerides Theologicae LovaniensesControls the uncertainty of a date based primarily on comparative script.